EEOC Revokes Prior Guidance on Criminal Screenings for Employment
On October 29, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) voted 2-1 to rescind Obama-era guidance concerning employers' obligations and limitations in using arrest and conviction records when screening job applicants. Per the public statement from the EEOC, the rescission is effective immediately.
The decision revokes the April 2012 guidance issued during the Obama administration. The former guidance cautioned employers against using criminal background checks for non-job related purposes. For example, employers were encouraged to consider the seriousness of the offense, the amount of time since the offense occurred, and whether the conduct was relevant to the position. The guidance further distinguished arrests from final convictions as far as establishing whether an applicant had committed criminal activity. Otherwise, the guidance cautioned employers unfairly evaluating criminal histories to make employment decisions could potentially be found liable for violating Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Title VII prohibits employers from discriminating against workers based on protected factors such as race, national origin, and sex. The more obvious concern was that an employer may treat one applicant differently from another applicant, despite having similar criminal histories, based on racial biases. The prior guidance also warned about the possibility that a policy of refusing to hire applicants with a criminal history, even if neutral on its face, could disproportionately exclude applicants based on race or national origin without a sufficient business justification—often called "disparate impact" discrimination.
The EEOC's decision to withdraw this guidance demonstrates the commission's 2025 change in position to deprioritize enforcement of disparate impact liability cases, instead focusing on claims of intentional discrimination.
Despite the revocation, EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas issued a statement reminding employers they are not free to engage in unlawful discrimination, and that Title VII still prohibits differential treatment based on race, national origin, and other employment "requirements" used as proxies for intentional discrimination. Instead, Lucas stated, the decision represents the EEOC's determination to enforce Title VII based on the express text of the statute, "consistent with the Constitution and the limits Congress placed on the EEOC's authority."
A dissenting vote came from the commission's sole Democrat, Kalpana Kotagal. In her opposition, Kotagal expressed her concerns about the rescission being confusing to employers while also adversely affecting employment opportunities for workers.
Notably, the rescission of the April 2012 guidance does not require employers to change their employment screening practices; employers may continue to use existing procedures that were adopted under that guidance. The EEOC simply will not be scrutinizing employers' screening procedures for possible disparate impacts based on criminal history. Employers likewise remain subject to state laws governing criminal background checks, which are not affected by the EEOC decision.
For more information about your company's criminal history check, applicant screening, or similar procedures, please contact Nick Bertron, Amy Conway, Tracey Holmes Donesky, Leena Fry, April Petrosino, Stephanie Scheck, Joel Spann, Dawn Valdivia, Sara Welch or the Stinson LLP contact with whom you regularly work.

